The Infamous ‘Tartan Ribbon’
The James Clerk Maxwell and Thomas Sutton Saga with Historical Context and Technical Clarifications
By Paul Elter
May 17, 1861, Jamers Clerk Maxwell delivered a lecture at the Royal Society where he through a lackluster lanternslide projection demonstration, validated his theory for colour perception in the human eye via the additive colour process known today as RGB. Three identical images of Maxwell’s Tartan Ribbon from three separate slide projectors were projected onto the wall of this august society. Chemical compounds in solution were then placed in front of each lens, replicating the ‘colour filters’ with which the object had been photographed by the inventor, writer, publisher and photographer Thomas Sutton – these images were carefully realigned, and that evening “the first colour photograph” was supposed to have been created. That story is, in fact, a lot more complex and many elements of it have been distorted and misinterpreted through innumerable retellings and have become somewhat of an urban legend – see for yourself as many a photography ‘influencer’ or photographic curator repeats the same factual error over and over.
This is a fascinating story of historical facts buried, distorted and hyped through time and a how a legend arises in such a way to help personal photographic inventors align themselves with hero’s of the scientific and photographic past, warping the truth along the way. Through a lengthy wetplate recreation and scientific experimentation we have discovered what was most likely a happy accident, but not at all any colour firsts, that is to say, not in any way that has been conjectured for over 160 years. As well, by means of this experiment we can clarify though demonstration, how photographic emulsions ‘see’ the visible colour spectrum and how their nature is biased to portions of that spectrum and cannot ever see beyond them, again sometimes contrary to popular belief and understanding.
This experiment was first conceptualized in the spring of 2021 with my colleague on the project Dr. Suzanne Klein and has been subsequently peer reviewed in two journals: Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and Theoretical and in the journal, Heritage. The whole lengthy schamozle can be found on my website blog along with all the links you need, there is so much in there it had to be two parts – enjoy (see below)
Paul Elter:
A career spanning 35 years in the museum and gallery sector devoted to analog and digital technologies and archiving infrastructures. Paul Elter is an artist, photographer, independent researcher and writer. The last 22 years of which, he managed and maintained the photographic logistics for digitization of the vast collection at The National Gallery of Canada some 300,000+ works of art including its exceptional photographic collection. Having worked in various capacities in both local and international museums from the Vancouver Art Gallery to the Yukon Art Gallery and during this long career having handled and photographed nearly 85.000 objects and installed numerous local and international exhibitions. Paul is also a wetplate collodion practioner of 20 years and various other photo-historic practices His upcoming publication: Silver Tongued (Fall 2025), is a culmination of itinerate story gathering, wetplate photography and poetry, this 300 page publication is an experiment in the capturing of serendipity and chemistry, of dialogue and the written word, created during a residency at the former home of the Canadian poet Al Purdy. Selected recent writings, lectures and publications, include: Royal Photographic Society Travel & the Mobile Darkroom, Silver, Salt & the Arctic Ocean (2020), Colour Fever Symposium at the Victoria & Albert Museum London, England: – Maxwell’s Disappointment / Sutton’s Accident (2021) Victoria & Albert Museum Dundee Scotland – Exhibition, Tartan (2023-24) Writer-in-Residence - Al & Eurithe Purdy A-Frame Ameliasburgh, ON (2023). Another Places Press UK (2023), Arctic Light – Field Notes 063. The cover image to: AnyWord – A Festschrift for Phil Hall (2024), Beautiful Outlaw Press CDN. Winner of the Yukon Advanced Artist Award, (2000) and Canada Council for the Arts, Creation and Exploration Award (2023). Currently residing in the beautiful Gatineau hills in Chelsea, Quebec Canada.
More reading material:
https://www.elter.ca/alizarin/2021/12/7/maxwells-first-colour-photograph-part-one
https://www.elter.ca/alizarin/2021/12/7/ebkt9istvpqp3bnhzk3sn5q1l78wvg